NATIONAL FRAUD INITIATIVE
The Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG) has been given new statutory powers to conduct data matching exercises for the purpose of assisting in the prevention and detection of fraud. The new powers are contained in Articles 4A to 4H of the Audit and Accountability (
What is Data Matching?
Data matching involves comparing sets of data, such as the payroll or benefits records of a body, against other records held by the same or another body. This allows potentially fraudulent claims and payments to be identified. Where no match is found, the data matching process will have no material impact on those concerned. Where a match is found it indicates that there may be an inconsistency that requires further investigation.
Code of Data Matching
The use of data for data matching purposes is governed by the C&AG’s Code of Data Matching Practice, the purpose of which is to help ensure that the C&AG, the Northern Ireland Audit Office, and all persons and bodies involved in data matching exercises comply with the law, especially the provisions of the Data Protection Act 1998 and to promote good practice in data matching. The Code was prepared in consultation with the Information Commissioner and other stakeholders and was laid by the Department of Finance and Personnel before the Assembly on
Key documents
Code of Data Matching Practice (144 KB, Adobe PDF Format)
NFI-in-northern-ireland-instructions.pdf (134 KB, Adobe PDF Format)
Layered Fair Processing Notice - Level 3.pdf (25 KB, Adobe PDF Format)
Other information can be obtained at:
NFI Workshop 18th February 2009
NIAO, in conjunction with the Audit Commission, held two half day workshops on 18th February 2009.
All bodies participating in the 2008-09 NFI Exercise were invited to attend and it total, some 156 representatives from 69 bodies attended either of the sessions.
Janet Sides, NIAO, opened the session by providing participants with an update position on the NFI Exercise in
Nathan Nash, Audit Commission, gave delegates information on the types of matches that they will receive and advice on how best to deal with them. His presentation also included a comprehensive demonstration of the NFI secure website.
Patrick O’Neill, NIAO, concluded the session by giving delegates an overview of NIAO’s perspective on handling suspected fraud. Patrick also highlighted two documents that may be of use to those investigating potential frauds; ‘Common
Methods and Types of Fraud’, and ‘Indicators of Fraud’ – it should be noted that these are not intended to be exhaustive lists and should be tailored to bodies’ individual circumstances. These documents along with copies of all presentations made on the day can be accessed at the links below:
Documents
Common Methods and Types of Fraud.pdf
Presentations
Audit Commission - NI NFI participants.pdf
NIAO's perspective on handling suspected frauds.pdf
National Fraud Initiative 2008/09
The first data matching exercise under the C&AG’s new powers will be undertaken in 2008/09. The Audit Commission for Local Authorities and the National Health Service in England (the Audit Commission), which has been conducting a sophisticated data matching exercise since 1996 under the banner of the National Fraud Initiative (NFI) (www.audit-commission.gov.uk/nfi), will carry out key aspects of the exercise on behalf of the C&AG, including the collection and processing of data.
The data obtained for the 2008/09 exercise will be matched on a cross jurisdictional basis in the
Instructions for NFI in Northern Ireland 2008/09
The roles and responsibilities of participants are set out in the document, National Fraud Initiative in Northern Ireland 2008/09 Instructions and can be accessed at: NFI in Northern Ireland Instructions. These instructions also provide full details of the 2008/09 timetable and the data specifications
Fair Processing Notices
In accordance with the Code of Data Matching Practice, participants in the C&AG’s data matching exercises should inform individuals that their data will be processed as required by the Data Protection Act 1998.
The Information Commissioner recommends a layered approach to fair processing notices. Usually there are three layers: summary notice, condensed text and full text. Taken together, the three layers comprise the fair processing notice.
The full text includes an explanation of the legal basis for the C&AG’s data matching exercises and a more detailed description of how the Initiative works. This can be accessed at: Layered Fair Processing Notice Level 3
Public Accounts Committee Hearing
The Public Accounts Committee received a presentation on the NFI at its meeting on 3 April 2008. The Committee views the NFI as a key tool in the armoury against fraud and error, issues which the Committee has consistently highlighted in other reports
To oversee the subsequent operation of NFI, the Committee intends to review its outworkings. Given that the C&AG intends to carry out a stocktake following the proposed October 2008 exercise, the Committee will call him to report on the results of the initiative at that stage. The C&AG will also publish a report on the Exercise.
The Report of the Committee can be viewed at:
Press Notices
NIAO: Press Releases - Consultation on Data Matching Practice issued March 2008
Further Information
Patrick O’Neill
NFI Coordinator
( 02890 251023
nficoordinator@niauditoffice.gov.uk
Patricia Blair
NFI Coordinator
( 02890 251004
nficoordinator@niauditoffice.gov.uk
Links
www.audit-commission.gov.uk/nfi

